Bloomberg’s Latest ‘Nanny’ Move: Pushing People to Take the Stairs


bloomberg-nanny-smallFirst he came after the cigarettes. Then the trans-fats. Then the super-sized drinks. Now, Mayor Michael Bloomberg is coming after the elevators.

City officials announced a new initiative this afternoon aimed at encouraging office workers to take the stairs instead of waiting for the elevator. Under legislation proposed by the mayor, all new buildings and buildings undergoing major renovation would be required to give occupants access to at least one stairwell, as well as post signs near elevators pointing to nearby stairs.

Another bill would increase the visibility of stairwells by permitting the use of hold-open devices on doors that would close automatically in case of an emergency.

“Whether you’re tall or short, fat or thin, you’ll be healthier and you’ll live longer if you’re more active. But the problem is we’ve been lulled into a sedentary lifestyle,” said Department of Design and Construction Commissioner David Burney at a Manhattan press conference at The New School. In too many buildings, the stairs are hard to find, kept locked, armed with alarms, or dark and windowless-making people afraid to use them, Health Commissioner Thomas Farley said. The programs are designed to change that, he said.

As part of the effort, officials also announced the creation of the “Center for Active Design,” a non-profit organization that will be tasked with finding ways to design healthier buildings, promote public transit and create more inviting outdoor spaces for activity. Mr. Bloomberg also announced a new executive order requiring all agencies to use these strategies when performing new construction or major renovations.

Mr. Bloomberg, who said he personally almost always uses the stairs-and doesn’t stand still when he’s on an escalator-said that part of the challenge was to make being active hipper for young people across the city.

“What we’ve got to do is just make it cool-if you will-or socially more the norm to exercise, and that’s what you see here,” he explained. “The whole idea is not to change what you have to do, but to give you the idea and the impetus to do something that is in your best interest.”

And-seemingly anticipating more headlines decrying his nanny state efforts-Mr. Bloomberg argued that they are in fact extremely popular, and one of the reasons why the city’s doing so well.

“Somebody asked me the other day: ‘Well isn’t all this nanny … stuff hurting business?’ And I pointed out we had a record number of companies moving here, we had record-number of private sector jobs here, we had record-number of tourists.”

“Stop me when you get bored,” he added. “I mean, these are things that most people like.”


{ Newscenter}


  1. I am waiting to see all the sarcastic, debasing comments on the mayor for this one, but you American people should take a good look in the mirror. Inside the photos, I see that most of you are grossly overweight and are heading towards developing some of the worst and inevitable diseases indicative of the modern lifestyle, to be multiplied by the weekly kiddushes, gourmet Shabbos meals, Yom Tov, etc.
    Surely, that doesn’t condone most of his policies, but – please- call a spade, a spade. This time, he’s right. “Tishmoru ul Nafshosachem” !!!!!!

  2. Mr. Bloomberg is never going to get New Yorkers into shape by being their “nanny”. The only way people go on diets or do exercise is if they themselves are motivated themselves, whether for health reasons or personal image etc. They need incentives for wanting to shape up. Maybe Bloomberg should offer monetary rewards from his vast coffers for people who follow his suggestions and get to their goals.

  3. Take a look at shaarei tzedek in yerushalayim, where more often than not, most people including proffesors will take the (wide well lit) stairs if it is just a flight or two down or up