Har Hazeisim Remains a “National Disgrace:” How Could That Be?


har-hazeisim1By Menachem Lubinsky

It was five years ago that Avrohom Lubinsky rang the alarm bells that the holy 3000-year old cemetery, Har Hazeisim, had become nothing short of what a Jewish leader called “a national disgrace.” The State Comptroller at the time Micha Lindenstrauss agreed, issuing a stinging report about the “neglect and abuse” by successive governments of a bais hachaim where 150,000 Jews over centuries were buried. He described, and members of the newly created committee corroborated on what they found: an area of hundreds of broken and desecrated graves, donkey races, soccer games, dumping ground for construction waste, and even thriving drug traffic. And all of us collectively asked, “How could that be?”

Thanks to Jewish community leaders like Malcolm Hoenlein, the Vice Chairman of the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations, other Jewish leaders and activists, and the unrelenting determination of Avrohom who founded the International Committee for the Preservation of Har Hazeisim (ICPHH), a new era of change came upon Har Hazeisim. Roads were repaired, destroyed graves restored, a surveillance monitoring station constructed, 137 surveillance cameras installed, and a police substation established. Indeed, at times it seemed that serious attempts were being made to protect and develop Har Hazeisim, especially since the government periodically released details of new projects to be implemented, such as a Visitor’s Educational Center and even a cable car to facilitate transportation to Har Hazeisim.

But then just as we were lulled into a false sense of security, we were jolted by events. The chelka of Ger, where two admorim, the Bais Yisroel and the Lev Simchah zt”l, are interred was desecrated, albeit that the hooligans were not able to penetrate the iron door that leads to the maarah where they lie. But the matzeivos of such luminaries as Harav Yitzchok Meir Levine zt”l, the indefatigable Agudist leader, were not so lucky as they were meticulously destroyed. Eyewitnesses described how the Arabs used axes and large boulders to destroy the graves. And again you ask, “How could that be?” especially after three incidences within a period of five months.

The “How could it be?” question can be pointed in many different directions. Where are the people that monitor the cameras? Where are the police that are supposed to man the sub-station on Har Hazeisim? Where are the 24 police officers the government promised when the police station opened? And lastly, where is the government with all of its pronouncements and declarations about its commitment to the security of Mizrach Yerushalayim? While it is true that the vandals destroyed the cameras in the area of the Gerer chelka and that the police attempted to approach the area but were rebuffed by burning tires, you wonder how this is possible in 2015 when Israel proclaims its sovereignty over the entirety of Yerushalayim. But then for a period of a few weeks, Har Hazeisim returns to “normal.” This is defined as Arab schoolchildren on their way home from school periodically heaving rocks on visitors and mourners. A car making its way to Har Hazeisim to daven at the kever of a loved one is stoned and its windows shattered. You may say however, that there are occasional days when the border police do show up in force, but like the sun setting in the evening, they are gone by morning.

In a major expose in the Maariv newspaper, Kalman Lipskind makes note of the disgrace. He vividly describes the desecrated graves, the fear of visiting the grave of a loved one, and even how local Arabs continue to expand their homes right up to graves on Har Hazeisim. Lipskind’s article published just a few days ago, may detail the shocking state of Har Hazeisim, but one can only imagine what it would have looked like five years ago before the ICPHH prompted major changes. His conclusion however is extremely disturbing: “The Prime Minister will continue to speak of a united Yerushalayim for eternity. The Mayor will proclaim that he is the mayor of Yerushalayim in its entirety. The President will continue to greet us with ‘Good Morning from Yerushalayim.’ The State of Israel is truly not interested in exercising its sovereignty over Yeushalayim.” His conclusions are pretty frightening but we will continue to wonder “How could that be?”

If that is indeed the case, the government of Israel may be in for a surprise. World Jewry is not about to abandon the place where the kohanim prepared for the avodah in the Bais Hamikdash, where the ashes of the poroh haadumah were buried, where Dovid Hamelech fled from Shaul, where three neviim are buried and where 150,000 Jews, including the foremost leaders of klal yisroel from almost every country in the world are buried. It is estimated that more than 10,000 Americans are interred there as are more than 14,000 French Jews, just to name two countries. After all, every Jew in the long and bitter golus dreamt of burial on Har Hazeisim, with its stated benefits of being first in techiyas hameisim and lying just opposite the mokom hamikdash. Aside from the kedusha, world Jewry has an enormous stake on the holy mountain. My parents are buried there and I make sure to visit their kevorim on their yahrtzeits. I and my brother are not about to accept Lipskind’s nonchalant  conclusions about the government’s disregard for that part of Yerushalayim.

Last year when Harav Moshe Tuvia Lieff called an asifa in his home to support the work of the ICPHH, the crowd overflowed into the streets forcing the Moroh D’asroh of Agudas Yisroel Bais Binyomin to move the asifa this year (May 17th) to the Agudah of Avenue L. It is clear that these Jews are not about to bid farewell to this sacred place. Three years ago more than 1800 Jews filled the Great Synagogue in Yerushalayim in a show of solidarity that even included politicians from all the major factions, some who had not even been invited. Opposition leader MK Yitzchak Herzog wondered out loud at the gathering: “What would we have said if this situation on Har Hazeisim had occurred somewhere in Europe?” And you say, after all this, how could it be that the police station is often manned like a satellite branch of a bank, opening late and closing early, with only one or two officers to patrol almost 3 kilometers of an area in a very hostile neighborhood.

It is extremely difficult to understand why the task of securing Har Hazeisim fell to Jews living in Brooklyn and other areas. By the same token, how is it that almost every government official, irrespective of political or religious affiliation, “thanks” us for our efforts. They live within a stone’s throw. Is it only our responsibility? How could that be?

Could it be that Har Hazeisim is more important to the Arabs than it is to us, despite the kedusha and history? After all, they seem to have a very clear plan to deny us our past. They destroy and trample on our graves and don’t even allow us to mourn. Their maps call Har Hazeisim the Ras al Amud neighborhood. Some Arab families even live right in the cemetery. How could that be?

Those of us who have embarked on this task of bringing change to Har Hazeisim are under no illusions of the difficult road ahead. There is some hope that a new government that has included the security of Har Hazeisim in its coalition agreements will finally show muscle in securing the 3000-year old Har Hazeisim. For the ICPHH, basic security on Har Hazeisim and the approach roads will be a major achievement, but our agenda is far more ambitious. The cemetery needs to be repaired and cleaned, and we need to demonstrate that kovod hameis is paramount in Judaism. Two important projects will be to build a tall maximum security wall to keep vandals out, and to prompt the Knesset to adopt tough new laws against the rock throwers. For now, every Jew must feel the shame of this national disgrace and must ask: “How Could This Be?”


Menachem Lubinsky is the President and CEO of Lubicom Marketing Consulting in Brooklyn, NY. He is also the Co-Chairman of the International Committee for the Preservation of Har Hazeisim.

{Matzav.com Newscenter}