Haskel Lookstein: I Am DONE With the New York Times

13

On Wednesday morning, May 1, a couple of hours after returning home from a glorious Passover in Israel, my wife and I called The New York Times and explained to a very respectful representative why we wanted to end 60 years of on-and-off home delivery of the paper. We told him that the cartoon that was published in The New York Times International Edition on Thursday, April 25 — depicting a guide dog with Benjamin Netanyahu’s face leading a blind, fat Donald Trump wearing dark glasses and a black kippa — crossed every boundary that separates us from virulent antisemitism, bigotry, and obscenity. It exposed, in our eyes, something rotten in what used to be known as “the paper of record” and brought the Times to a level which might have been acceptable in Germany in the 1930s, but is intolerable in our world today.

The decision to dump the Times was not easy, but it was necessary. Twice during the last 25 years, I have launched campaigns to temporarily suspend delivery of The New York Times because of its unfair — a mild term — treatment of Israel in its news columns and editorial pages. The most recent campaign was after Passover 2002, when the IDF invaded the West Bank to stop the explosive growth of terrorism inside Israel that had caused more than 1,000 deaths and countless injuries during the previous 12 months. Many responded to that call and also to the suggestion that synagogues stop placing paid death notices on the obituary pages of the Times — which now, as a result, are much smaller than before.

After the suspension, we personally resumed receiving the paper’s Saturday and Sunday editions because of the special sections that are so enticing. After April 25, however — with the publication of the obscene cartoon savaging the Jewish people, the prime minister of Israel, and the president of the United States — it became clear to us that The New York Times has no place in our home or, for that matter, in any respectable home, Jewish or not.

We are living in a world of increasingly active — and often violent — antisemitism. Those who hate us from the left and the right have taken off the gloves. They now feel emboldened by the media and even by political leaders to say things, to write words, and to print cartoons that would have been viewed as repulsive and grotesque as recently as two or three years ago.

I don’t claim to know why this has happened; I can only look at the America in which we live, at the England that used to be a model of civility, at France and the rest of Western Europe where Jews no longer feel safe, and draw one conclusion: It is up to every decent American, and especially every serious Jew, to stand up and do whatever he or she can do to fight this frightening trend before it continues further.

Thank God, unlike in the 1930s and ‘40s, we have organizations that are active, outspoken and, hopefully, will take the mantle of leadership in a battle that must be fought and won. But what can each of us as individuals do? The answer is to refuse to accept vicious antisemitism whenever it is published, broadcast, or televised. Each of us must protest and not simply kvetch.

In the case of The New York Times, as Alan Dershowitz, in his recent brilliant critique argued, it may very well be that freedom of speech entitles it to print whatever it pleases, but you and I have a responsibility to denounce vicious caricatures of Jews and Zionists whenever and wherever we see them. Dershowitz writes that he will continue to read the Times in order to be able to refute it. You and I do not have that luxury. No one will listen to our refutations. We have one major recourse by which we can let our revulsion be known: We can refuse to let The New York Times enter our homes.

It is a small action, but if it is taken by many individuals, it will deliver a strong message. If we believe that antisemitism is on the rise, and that it presents a danger to the Jewish people and to the America that we love, we have to do more than worry about it. We have to believe that our acts will make a difference and will help to purify the culture and the politics that are changing before our eyes. Take action now. It is time to dump the Times!

Rabbi Haskel Lookstein is the Rabbi Emeritus of Congregation Kehilath Jeshurun on the Upper East Side of Manhattan.

13 COMMENTS

  1. I am not sure why anyone would even order a subscription to that anti semitic paper even 30 years ago. The fact that the Times buried the Holocaust to its middle to back pages should have been enough of a reason never to buy or read that paper

  2. Rabbi Haskel Lookstein שליט״א is a צדיק יסוד עולם, a גאון בתורה, a פוסק that has ש״ס & שולחן ערוך on his fingertips. He’s an איש קדוש that has the צורה of a מלאך השם. That he canceled his subscription to The NY Times after 60 years is a testament to his גדלות.

    • Haha. Good One. Sad that anti-semitism is the only thing that turned him off. It should but what about the lack of tzenius and bringing in shmutz into his house. It is a sad testament to Modern Orthodoxy that a supposed “Rabbi” would not be ashamed to say that he brings this into his house.

  3. What? You launched a campaign not to get the Times and then you got it yourself personally? Did i read that right?

  4. Dear Rabbi,
    All I can say is what took you so long??
    The NY Times may have been required even enjoyable reading for you. For most others slightly to the right of your modern orthodox liberal minded NYC congregation this rag of a paper has not been worthy of entering orthodox Jewish homes to be used even as toilet paper or cat litter for close to 5 decades already.
    May I suggest that now that you have given up your favorite source of “what’s going on in the world” don’t bother replacing it rather stick to the books of our people in which I’m sure you are well versed and let your future sermons be lectures on torah machshava and musar/chasidus etc. rather than politics and blasting the latest anti Israel piece in the NYT. This will be a benefit to you and your congregation who as Jews who come to shul are certainly tzama ldvar HaShem even if they don’t know it yet.

  5. Tzadik yesod olam? How many people line up in front of his door for brachos? FYI the Tzadikim would probably not look at these “newspapers “ let alone subscribe

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here