In Germany, Israeli Orchestra to Play Hitler’s Favorite Composer


bayreuth-destival-wagnerAFP reports: Bayreuth, Germany – Germany’s 100th Wagner opera festival kicked off here today in an edition that will include a taboo-busting performance by an Israeli orchestra.

The annual tribute to the works of the 19th-century composer, a fervent anti-Semite who later inspired Nazi leaders, will include for the first time a concert by musicians from Israel, which maintains an unwritten Wagner ban.

On Monday afternoon, German Chancellor Angela Merkel and European Central Bank chief Jean-Claude Trichet led a parade of political and business elites mounting Bayreuth’s famed Green Hill to the concert hall built in 1876.

Audiences were keenly awaiting the opening performance of “Tannhaeuser”, a romantic opera considered the seminal work of Wagner’s younger years, but the Israel Chamber Orchestra’s concert Tuesday was the hottest ticket in town.

The musicians are scheduled to perform Wagner’s “Siegfried Idyll” during a concert otherwise dominated by works by Jewish composers including Gustav Mahler and Felix Mendelssohn.

Performances of Wagner’s work are almost unheard of in Israel.

When Israeli-Argentine conductor Daniel Barenboim led the Berlin Staatskapelle in a performance of an excerpt from “Tristan und Isolde” in Jerusalem in 2001, dozens of audience members stormed out.

Israel Chamber Orchestra first clarinettist, 27-year-old Dan Erdmann, said he had attended that concert with his father.

“He (Barenboim) indicated to those who wanted to leave to do so but at the same time, the orchestra was ready to play for those who chose to stay,” he told AFP.

“Thirty or forty people left, some of them shouting and cursing and slamming the doors. The rest stayed and gave a standing ovation at the end.”

Ten years on, the Israeli concert is not part of the official Bayreuth Festival programme but it has nonetheless set some tempers flaring.

“The decision of the Israel Chamber Orchestra sadly represents an act of moral failure and a disgraceful abandonment of solidarity with those who suffered unspeakable horrors by the purveyors of Wagner’s banner,” said Elan Steinberg, vice president of the American Gathering of Holocaust Survivors and their Descendants.

“Nobody suggests that Wagner’s music not be played. But the public Jewish refusal to do so was a powerful message of indignation to the world that exposed Wagner’s odious anti-Semitic ideas and those who championed them.”

The city of Bayreuth and the Wagner family, which notoriously courted Nazi leader Adolf Hitler, are meanwhile trying to break with the past.

Bayreuth plans to start a Jewish cultural centre while Katharina Wagner, the 32-year-old great-granddaughter of the composer and co-director of the festival, has pledged to open the family archives revealing the extent of her ancestors’ entanglement with the Nazis.

Felix Gothart, a leader of the Bayreuth Jewish community, which now has about 500 members, twice the number in 1933 when Hitler came to power, was also critical of the decision to invite the Israeli musicians to play this year.

“As soon as a single person was offended by the fact that Wagner is being played by Jews in Germany it would have been better to keep a lower profile,” he told AFP.

However the president of Israel’s fledgling Wagner society said he was delighted that an Israeli orchestra would be performing in Bayreuth, saying it could represent a new beginning.

“I hope that the concert will mark a new step towards the lifting of the taboo in Israel against Wagner, one of the principal composers of the 19th century, and that he will soon by performed freely in our country,” Jonathan Livni said.

{AFP/ Newscenter}


  1. As to Barenboim’s playing Wahner in Israel, the account here leaves out that he had promised not to. Then, he did so anyways.

    Barenboim, like Wagner, moral flea, great musician.

  2. Why would jews want to play the music of Hitler’s favorite composer? There are still a few hundred thousand survivors of the Holocaust left in the world. I guess some people have no shame, no integrity and no sense of history. Shame on you.

  3. The same guys who criticize the Netura Karta for befriending the Hitler of Iran are now doing this tinoifus. A meshugene velt. Efsher velen zei gein tantzen oif Bloombergs chasuna.

  4. Disgraceful. This chamber orchestra. unfortunately, might represent the state of Israel, but surely not the Jewish people! Just another chilul Hashem added on to all the rest that is constantly being committed by today’s so-called Israelis.

  5. Actually, I think Beethoven is greater. (But really, I am his friend, but I am Bach’s greatest fan. Play more Bach).

  6. Sounds like people have not read the story.

    The orchestra does not represent the state of Israel. The State has criticized them for this.

    It is one group of musicians doing this on their own.

  7. “…. Wagner, moral flea, great musician.”

    No true. Wagner was morally bankrupt (seduced his best friend’s wife) and composed trashy music. He’s held in high esteem not because of the quality of his music but mostly because of his anti-Semitism. As Titus harasha advises Unkulos in meseches Gittin, if one wants to achieve great honor in this world, he should give Jews a hard time. Wagner definitely is one such example. Germans have exceptional composers, Bach, Brahms, Beethoven, among others. Wagner is not one of them.

  8. Richard Wagner was a low life and played music by jewish composers wearing gloves.

    Maybe they should also play his “music” also wearing gloves!!!!

    Its more than just music Wagner’s Music is dedicated to Germanic dieties and Mythology.

    We have to realize that the state of Israel is a state made by some jews…but is NOT a jewish state.

  9. thats why we need our chabad and other outreach because our own people are so lost and we need to have experienced people helping them to feel welcome to come back. this is very sad.