Jewish Berkeley Couple Takes Up the Challenge: $50 Food Budget for One Week


foodstampedFrom a JWeekly report by Stacey Palevsky:  Shira and Yoav Potash consider themselves “eco-kashrus,” a practice and philosophy that finds the Berkeley couple shopping for organic, local produce, and grass-fed, free-range, hormone-free, sustainably raised poultry and beef.
“We want as many adjectives in front of our meat as possible,” Yoav joked. “So that means we spend a lot of money, normally.” But when the couple committed to trying the “food stamp challenge” for one week, meat was the first thing they eliminated from their shopping list.The challenge is a charge to people not relying on government-issued food stamps to eat for one week only what they could afford if they actually received the federal subsidy. The food stamp challenge garnered publicity in 2007 when the governor of Oregon and members of Congress participated in the experiment.

For Shira and Yoav, the food stamp challenge allowed each a budget of about $3.50 a day, or $50 total, for one week.

As a result, “We couldn’t afford to buy the meat we feel comfortable eating,” Shira said.

The couple chronicled their “food stamp diet” and the result is “Foodstamped,” a documentary.

Shira teaches nutrition and cooking classes in the Hayward Unified School District. When she heard about the challenge, “I started thinking: Here I am, trying to teach kids who are eligible for food stamps how to cook, but how am I supposed to know what they can afford to cook?

“I thought maybe I should take the challenge and see how it is.”

In March of this year, 33.2 million low-income Americans received food stamps, an all-time record high, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture.

Shira wondered: Could a person live on food stamps for one week and still eat nutritious meals?

And since her husband, Yoav, is a documentary filmmaker, she figured, “Why not make a little movie about it? We thought it would be five or 10 minutes long and something we’d put on YouTube. But it’s evolved into something much bigger.”

Yoav and Shira Potash shop for groceries at Berkeley Bowl in their documentary “Foodstamped.” After taking up the challenge in February 2008, they accumulated 75 hours of footage. The documentary they thought would be 10 minutes is now an hourlong film they hope will be broadcast on PBS.

Yoav, who admits he has a big appetite, initially was wary of living on a food-stamp budget. Shira promised to take care of the shopping and cooking, and also agreed to treat Yoav to a big brunch a day before their journey began.

They started by making a shopping list of economical, healthy foods from a range of food groups, such as dried beans, lentils, oats, eggs, fruits and vegetables.

With a calculator and video camera in tow, they walked around Berkeley Bowl and bought $48.82 worth of food.

They saved the remaining $1.18 for Shabbos. The couple turned in their bottles and cans at a redemption center for an additional 82 cents. But the $2 wasn’t quite enough to purchase a loaf of bread for Shabbos.

“We ideally wanted to buy a challah, but we discovered we couldn’t afford a challah,” Yoav said. “The cheapest bread was a baguette, but it was $2.09, and we only had $2. So we went to the cash register, and luckily, someone behind us in line offered us some change. In the end, we had to depend on the kindness of strangers.”

After embarking on the challenge, they interviewed dozens of people for the film: People actually living on food stamps, people applying for food stamps for the first time, people who work at food banks and in food policy in the California legislature. They even had a nutritionist grade the meals they ate during the week.

As Shira predicted, making “Foodstamped” has helped her design more appropriate lessons and recipes for her students. And she now includes a priced-out shopping list with all the recipes she sends home to students.

“Everybody deserves to eat healthy food, and healthy food does not have to be expensive or a luxury. But the way our system is set up, that’s how it is – and it’s really unfortunate,” Shira said. “I would like people [who view the film] to feel empowered to take action and change that.”

{JWeekly/ Newscenter}


  1. I work in an inner city neighborhood and most of my clients who are on food stamps also have a few – usually more than two TVS with every channel available and they are constantly ordering out food and they have the fanciest phones and other gadgets. Let them live within their means and there would be a lot less issues.