NYC Frum Family In Israel: US Remains Land Of ‘Freedom’


aviva-and-seth-goldsteinAviva and Seth Goldstein left their families and a fantastic life in the Bronx for what is perceived by many as a country torn by war and conflict.

One year after their move you couldn’t find a happier and more enthusiastic family in Jerusalem. Aviva’s huge and warm smile doesn’t vanish from her face as she juggles a move to a new apartment and raising three girls: Aliana, 7, Tahila, 5, and Liba, 3.

For Aviva and Seth coming to Israel wasn’t about finding a greener pasture somewhere else – but as Jews they felt like not coming to the Holy Land was like standing on the sidelines of history. It was always a place that just called to them, where they dreamed of living.

As the Goldstein family lay down a nice picnic spread near the old Jerusalem railway tracks, an area dubbed as the Israeli version of New York City’s High Line, I asked Aviva and Seth what America represents for them and what role America has in the world today.

“The first thing that would come to mind when you think of America is liberty and freedom,” Seth said. “I don’t think the U.S. has retreated from that identity and I don’t think it lost a piece of that identity. I think it stands for freedom and democracy [now] as much as ever.”

“For me,” Aviva said, “America is also freedom and liberty. But I think that there is a big piece of America that’s comfort, with liberty and security, and that there is mobility within that.”

‘Economic opportunity’

Both Aviva and Seth have had careers in education, but at this point Aviva described herself as a “full time mom,” while Seth works at the Shalem Center, a research institute in Jerusalem.

“I think America stands for economic opportunity as well,” Seth said. “Also for all sorts of religious opportunities, that go hand-in- hand with freedom. It really is a place that you can grow in all sorts of uninhibited ways and be successful in all sorts of remarkable ways.”

How did they think the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan changed America?

“I think it stretched America’s finances and it reminded the world that America stands for something more than just isolating itself in a bubble, but that it has a responsibility to the rest of the world,” Seth said. “The extent that America was involved in it is a reflection of its sense of responsibility to other nations, to other people, to humanity.”

NBC News speaks with citizens from around the globe, asking the question, ‘What Does America Mean to You?’

Aviva also believed the U.S. involvement in Iraq and Afghanistan was a positive thing. “I think that as Jews, who always had an interest in Israeli world politics, I think it was easier for us to see the evil,” said Aviva. “I think we’re used to being stuck with really bad neighbors, so on some level it was good that America was involved.”

As for their three girls, Aviva said the move has just caused them all to flourish, even though they miss their grandparents. “Thank god for iPads,” Aviva said. She was referring to the fact they can see and talk to their family back in the U.S. almost for free using the device and the Internet.

“Coming here is the fulfillment of a dream,” Aviva explained. “I remember when we were dating 10 years ago, walking the streets of Manhattan fantasying about raising our unborn children in Jerusalem and now it’s our reality. It’s nothing short of a miracle.”

{Maximum News Informer/ Newscenter}


  1. BH what a great decision to bring up children in Eretz Yisroel, wishing you much success and lots of company of others who will follow in your footsteps.

  2. fortunate for them for taking the latest updated message of Hashem of the future.

    go now to eretz yisroel & go with fortune, wait & soon thousands will be going cause there will be no money left R”L & everyone will say/know the economy is better in Eretz yisroel DON’T WAIT! GO NOW

  3. Bs”D Eretz Yisroel has a neshoma which is Hashem’s gift to us, and it provides all the comfort, liberty and freedoms that a Jew could want and need. Home, sweet home.

  4. BE CAREFUL: There’s a very high percentage of children at risk/off the Derech from Americans that made Aliyah. Before anyone makes Aliyah, I highly suggest that one discuss it with a true Adam Gadol such as Reb Yosef Rosenbloom Shlit”a. Don’t follow your emotions on the expense of your children!

  5. “Aviva and Seth Goldstein left their families and a fantastic life in the Bronx”

    In the Bronx?! Fantastic?! Something is missing here.

  6. Stanley said: “In the Bronx?! Fantastic?! Something is missing here.”

    Ever hear of Riverdale? Technically, it is in the Bronx!