Small Group of U.S. Jews Fights for Right to Bear Arms


dovid-bendoryIn the year after the election of Barack Obama as president, more than 14 million weapons were sold in the United States compared with 12.7 million the year before. Gun-shop owners have argued that the rise in sales is linked in part to concerns that the Democratic administration will try to restrict the rights of Americans to hold weapons under license.

The Obama administration has not taken a clear stance on the issue, but in some U.S. states legal battles over the right to bear arms has begun in earnest.

So far Obama has been forced to sign into law the right to carry weapons in national parks, and also the right to bear arms in train compartments. Virginians, meanwhile, were given the right to carry concealed weapons in bars and restaurants, while a 17-year-old law banning the right to buy more than one gun per month was revoked.

In Indiana, companies may no longer prevent their employees from keeping arms in their cars parked on company property. Starbucks became the site of demonstrations by supporters and opponents of gun control after the coffee chain decided to allow customers in states where carrying arms is legal to enter its cafes carrying unconcealed weapons.

Much of the Jewish community has remained outside the debate: Some 90 million U.S. residents hold 200 million firearms, but only a tiny minority of American Jews have guns. However, there appears to be a revival among supporters of the right to bear arms among Jews who say that attitudes are changing because of new threats they face.

One of them is Dovid Bendory, an Orthodox rabbi, 42, from New Jersey. Not only did he buy a gun, he also became an authorized shooting instructor and is giving lessons to members of the Orthodox community. He also distributes material that explains, on the basis of biblical texts, the right of Jews to self-defense.

“I did not grow up with guns, not even with toy guns,” he says. “I think that the first time I saw a real gun was when I visited Israel at age 16. But I began to think about weapons seriously after the 9/11 terrorist attacks. As far as I’m concerned, the Twin Towers disaster changed the entire scene, because until then we thought that the terrorist threat existed only outside the United States.”

Another turning point was the terrorist attacks in Mumbai in November 2008, where one of the targets was the Chabad House.

“I realized that this is no longer political terrorism but anti-Semitism,” he says. “In May 2009 they arrested people in Riverdale, New York who wanted to blow up a synagogue in that neighborhood, which is a 40 minutes drive from my community.”

Bendory says the understanding that terrorism can reach America’s Jews, too, led to his decision to be ready.

Bendory took part in courses offered by an Israeli instructor, and then decided to disseminate his discoveries among the country’s Jewish community with a Web site and his “Ten Commandments for Self-Defense.”

“I think that in view of our history, every Jew who is physically and psychologically capable of carrying a gun should do so,” he says. “We must be ready to defend ourselves, and God will make sure we will never need to do so. I am not a supporter of Kahane, but I also do not want to find myself on the wrong side of a gun.”

About 30,000 people lose their lives in the United States as a result of gunfire every year, but in more than half the cases the shots are self-inflicted.

“I can’t see how restrictions on carrying arms would have helped in cases like the shooting at the Holocaust Museum in Washington in June 2009,” Bendory says. “As a felon, the shooter was not permitted to carry arms anyway, but he did not care about the law, and the only thing the law did was that none of the people in the Holocaust Museum had a weapon to protect themselves.

“It’s strange that so many Jewish Americans are proud of the IDF, but when a Jewish American speaks in favor of guns, they think he is mad. However, when I speak in the synagogue about the need for self-defense, suddenly people come out of the closet and admit that they have guns,” Bendory says.

“I put guns in the hands of dozens of people who held one for the first time. In my latest course I taught 12 Orthodox women to fire for the first time in a range,” Bendory says. He adds that non-Jews also contact him and encourage him.

William Daroff, director of the Washington office of the Jewish Federations of North America, believes that support for guns in the Jewish community is a marginal phenomenon; he says his organization does not have a set position on the matter.

Aaron Zelman from Wisconsin, who set up the organization Jews for the Preservation of Firearms Ownership 20 years ago recalled with nostalgia his first experience shooting a gun at a Jewish camp in Tucson, Arizona, where he grew up. “It would never happen today,” he says.

{Haaretz/ Newscenter}


  1. Can you imagine the Chofetz Chaim or Reb Moshe zatzal carrying a gun? What’s the point? Handguns are far more likely to kill family members accidentally than crooks intentionally.

    Plus, if you’ve ever used a gun or rifle (and I have) you know that you only hit what you’re aiming at around half the time or less. The police officers who shot Mr. Diallo in New York a few years back fired 40+ shots at a stationary target outlined against a lighted doorway. How many actually hit him? Nineteen – less than half. If there had been any bystanders around, any one of the other half of those rounds might have found a target in an innocent person, even a child.

    Think about it – you pull your gun to shoot a mugger – and instead hit a pregnant woman a hundred feet away, killing her and the baby. Yes, these things happen. Would you like to be the one who remembers this the rest of your life? Think carefully, very carefully, before you buy a gun.

  2. with today’s threat with militant Muslim’s in this country currently, i check every new guy that comes into shul with a bag……sorry but i do want to live!

  3. To Torah Hashkofa – So why did Yaakov Aveinu split his family into two armed camps when Eisov came calling? Why didn’t he throw all his swords and spears away and go to shul and pray?

    To Anonymous – Are you aware that towards the end of his life the Chofetz Chaim said if he were younger he would pick up a gun and go fight the communists himself? Also see above comment on Yaakov Aveinu. If it was good enough for him (and Avraham aveinu, Pinchos, Yehoshua,Dovod Hamelech, Mordechai and countless other prominent Jewish figures throughout history, I am sure it is good enough for us. However I will agree with you on one point. If you are so inept that you only hit what you are aiming at 50% of the time, you should stay as far away from firearms as your two little feet can carry you and leave proper self defense to those more capable. Fortunately that is about 98% of the population after proper training.

  4. Re: Comment from Anonymous

    WRONG – there are no statistics that bear this out – it is a made up stat by anti gun organizations. [“Handguns are far more likely to kill family members accidentally than crooks intentionally.”]

    WRONG – people that practice hit their targets. [“if you’ve ever used a gun or rifle (and I have) you know that you only hit what you’re aiming at around half the time or less.”]

    WRONG – there this is the extremely rare exception. You are obligated to defend yourself and others notwithstanding the (minimal) risk. [“Think about it – you pull your gun to shoot a mugger – and instead hit a pregnant woman a hundred feet away, killing her and the baby.”]

    Anonymous knows nothing about this subject and parrots the anti-gun line, believing what he sees on TV and in movies and not the numbers, readily available from law enforcement sources.

    Anonymous thinks it is better to die at the hands of a mugger than defend oneself or others. That is not a Jewish concept. It is a liberal concept.

    Get trained. Get armed. Stay safe.

    Kol tuv,


  5. I have seen the outright lies the anti gun lobby want us to believe.

    Armed we are a threat to the government. They can not do what they would like to as there could be dire consquenses.

    I notice that the anti gunner posts as anonamous

    It is just cowardly enough to fit.

    As a jew I resent anyone who would “protect me” as I do not need protection beyond what I can provide myself WITH a gun.

    I have used my gun 3 times in the last 15 years. Never had to fire a shot.

    So I didnt hit the pregnant woman who was out on the town at 3am.

    Look at the numbers and you will see that 50% of the time you shoot a family member is a lie. A L.I.E. it is not true.

    They will also tell you that it is more likely the bad guy will take your gun and shoot you with it. This is another L.I.E. it is not true.

    Many lies. If their stance were honest they would tell you that over a million times a year people defend themselves with firearms, a huge percentage never firing a shot.

    the numbers are out there. Look at them for yourself. Learn the truth, dont listen to someone who is afraid to be identified. They are only afraid because they know when the storm comes they will be on the wrong side.