Stringer: Walmart In NYC Would Be ‘Potentially Devastating’ To Local Economy


walmartNew York – Walmart has been trying to open a store in New York City for years, but the company has been met with lots of resistance.

Now in a new report, Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer is warning New Yorkers that the big box chain would only hurt, not help the city’s economy.

“This document that we’re releasing highlights the damage that Walmart would cause to the local retailers who have spent years and years building their businesses in a community that has struggled through this terrible recession,” Stringer said.

Stringer says if Walmart opened on 125th Street in Harlem, 25 percent of the nearby supermarkets and Bodegas would go out ofbusiness in a year and more would fail the second year.

He says millions of taxpayer dollars would also be jeopardized if Walmart opens in Harlem.

“Right now, there are two important city programs called Fresh and the Healthy Bodega Initiative where the city has spent millions in taxpayer dollars to help small businesses extend their fresh food retail space and we are concerned that Walmart would blow a hole in that,” Stringer said.

On its website, Walmart refuted Stringer’s study, saying “A new report from Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer that predicts that a Walmart in Harlem would hurt small businesses is nothing but a repackaging of a flawed Loyola University Chicago survey that tried unsuccessfully to make the same point.”

According to Walmart, there was positive economic development in Chicago after stores arrived there and that “the company actually created jobs in Chicago.”

The company also noted the opening of a Target store and Costco in Harlem and said that Stringer attended both openings.

Walmart says bringing the store to New York City would help bring fresh food to residents and that “Walmart can be part of the solution for New Yorkers who want more affordable healthy food options, period.”

The idea of a Walmart opening in New York City has been a hotly contested issue for some time.

Last month, Bronx Senator Ruben Diaz Sr. said he hopes to soon see a Walmart store in the city because he believes would benefit poorer residents.

In July, a Quinnipiac University poll found 69 percent of respondents said they would shop at a Walmart in the city if it was convenient.

That same poll showed that 63 percent of respondents said that city officials should allow a local Walmart to open.

{CBS New York/ Newscenter}


  1. At least two advertisers have withdrawn commercials from “All-American Muslim,” a new series on the TLC cable channel, since an activist organization called the Florida Family Association condemned the show.
    …Among the other advertisers that the Florida Family Association listed as agreeing to leave the series was Wal-Mart Stores.

  2. mr. stringer nyc is the highest taxed and costing city i
    n america because of liberal politicians such as yourself people should have the right to decide where they buy now thewy leave nyc abuy in long isla
    nd or nj where the tax dollar now goes

  3. This is the Bloomberg atitute. Don’t give hard working New Yorkers any breaks! Always try to stiff the taxpayers! Walmart would help struggling NY’s like no one else! I thought we live in a free market capitalism, country?! I guess, not in New York!