Yerushalayim: Anti-Giyus Protest Held with Backdrop of No Current IDF Chareidi Recruitment Requirements or Penalties


GIYUS[Photo Album 2 Below] As reported yesterday here on Matzav, thousands gathered in Meah Shearim yesterday to protest against recruitment of bnei yeshiva to the Israeli army and to express their opposition to new amendments to the Equal Service law.

In late November, the Knesset approved an amendment to the Equal Service law, which rolled back the 2014 reforms on chareidi recruitment into the IDF and scrapped all communal penalties imposed if annual quotas for chareidi soldiers were not met.

The protest was held even though there is currently no requirement for chareidi enlistment in the IDF.

The new version of the law pushed them off all communal penalties until 2023. So for the next 8 years, there will be no penalties for lack of chareidi recruitment, providing, in essence, blanket exemptions from the army for Torah study during the next 8 years.

Still, protest organizers said that the protest was held because of the claim that “the United Torah Judaism party has in effect agreed to the principle of chareidi enlistment by accepting the amendments.”


1ab91987-9f47-47f9-8507-64cc211357314c7df1bf-b10f-4bbd-9c6b-c2eacf6fe6c4 resized_DSC_0288 resized_DSC_0293 resized_DSC_0305 resized_DSC_0317 resized_DSC_0329 resized_DSC_0334 resized_DSC_0346 resized_DSC_0356 resized_DSC_0360 resized_DSC_0363 resized_DSC_0365 resized_DSC_0380 resized_DSC_0406 resized_DSC_0407 resized_DSC_0414 resized_DSC_0417 resized_DSC_0418 resized_DSC_0436 resized_DSC_0451 resized_DSC_0457 resized_DSC_0460 resized_DSC_0461 resized_DSC_0465 resized_DSC_0466 resized_DSC_0484 resized_DSC_0494 resized_DSC_0497 resized_DSC_0507 resized_DSC_0512 resized_DSC_0518 resized_DSC_0521 resized_DSC_0528 resized_DSC_0541 resized_DSC_0551 resized_DSC_0552 resized_DSC_0554 resized_DSC_0558 resized_DSC_0560 resized_DSC_0562 resized_DSC_0563 resized_DSC_0567 resized_DSC_0587 resized_DSC_0589 resized_DSC_0593 resized_DSC_0597 resized_DSC_0598 resized_DSC_0614 resized_DSC_0621

{ Israel News Bureau}


  1. Why does the press report as if there is no charedi draft requirement? There certainly is. All the amendments did was push off and delay the criminal punishment phase. Currently, people who want to sit and learn can get a deferral so long as they are learning full-time in yeshiva. Any charedi young man who is not in full-time yeshiva learning, up to age 22, certainly does have an obligation and can in fact go to jail if he does not serve in the IDF. Draft notices are still being received and recruitment is still going on, and the only way to avoid service in the IDF is if you are in full-time learning, but as of right now, any boy who does not want to sit and learn full-time must serve. It is also ILLEGAL to work.