Ireland’s impending implementation of the most stringent health warnings globally for alcoholic beverages has raised concerns among countries involved in alcohol production, asserting that these labels will hinder trade.
Ahead of the World Trade Organization committee meetings this week, the US and Mexico have expressed their reservations regarding the legislation. Argentina, Australia, Chile, Cuba, and New Zealand have also voiced their concerns about the recently passed law in Ireland. Despite receiving approval from the European Commission, several wine and beer-producing member countries within the European Union have opposed the measure.
Set to take effect in 2026, the labels will prominently display red-lettered warnings on every alcoholic beverage container, alerting consumers to the risks of liver disease, cancer, and alcohol consumption during pregnancy. The unease among alcohol producers reflects their apprehension of being targeted similarly to the cigarette industry, where warnings have evolved to include graphic images of tobacco-related diseases.
Last month, Canada introduced a requirement for health warnings to be printed on each individual cigarette.
Coldiretti, Italy’s largest association of farmers, has criticized Ireland’s proposed alcohol labels as “alarmist” and setting a “dangerous precedent.” The European Committee of Wine Companies has argued that these warnings create an “unjustified and disproportionate barrier to trade.”
Irish Health Minister Stephen Donnelly remains resolute in his support for the warnings.
In an interview with the national broadcaster RTÉ, he emphasized, “The majority of people are unaware of these risks. If the industry suggests waiting a little longer, the answer is a resounding no.”
Alcohol-Related Deaths
According to preliminary data from the OECD based on 2021 figures, Ireland ranks 20th out of 48 countries in terms of alcohol consumption. In 2019, alcohol was responsible for nearly one in every 20 deaths in the country, while light to moderate drinking levels contributed to almost 23,000 new cases of cancer in 2017, as reported by the Department of Health.
The European Commission conducted a thorough assessment of the legislation over the past year and found no objections, as Ireland demonstrated that the law aligns with public health objectives, according to a spokesperson for the Brussels-based body. The commission concluded that the impact on the EU single market is not significant enough to warrant concern.
In February, a group of nine countries, including France, Italy, and Spain, submitted a letter to the European Commission, urging them to examine the legality of Ireland’s law.
As stated in the letter obtained by Bloomberg News, these countries expressed that the law “sets a harmful precedent for the free movement of products among the various member states of the European Union.” The other nations involved were Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, Greece, Slovakia, Portugal, and Hungary.
To facilitate implementation for the industry, Ireland will allow the warnings to be applied using stickers. The law also mandates the inclusion of a crossed-out image depicting a pregnant woman drinking, along with information on the beverage’s calorie content and alcohol volume.
Ireland has gained recognition as a pioneer in addressing health issues. In 2004, it became the first country to enforce a ban on smoking in workplaces, bars, and restaurants. While controversial initially, this measure has since been adopted across Europe and in many other countries.
Critics within the alcohol industry, including the European Committee of Wine Companies, argue that the warnings fail to differentiate between alcohol abuse and moderate consumption.
However, according to the World Health Organization, no amount of alcohol consumption is entirely safe for health. The agency asserts that alcohol is linked to at least seven types of cancer, including common forms such as bowel and breast cancer.
Frank Murray, a consultant hepatologist and chairman of Alcohol Action Ireland, emphasizes the clear evidence linking alcohol to cancer, drinking during pregnancy, and liver damage.
What about cancer warnings on the 2021 covid jabs that millions have died or maimed from?
How many people have died from beer and wine since 2021?