Watch: Commander of Gush Katif Expulsion Admits Mistake 13 Years Later

11

Maj. Gen. (Res.) Gershon Hacohen, Begin-Sadat Center for Strategic Studies giving a retrospective look at the 2005 disengagement from Gush Katif.

WATCH:

11 COMMENTS

  1. WHAT DID RABBI MEIR KAHANA SAY ABOUT THIS?
    ANYONE REMEMBER IF HE SAID TO GIVE LAND AWAY…
    OOOOH WAIT A MINUTE……..
    WHAT DID G-D SAY ABOUT GIVING AWAY””MY LAND””

  2. I’m usually very right wing but I still think the Gaza disengagement was the right thing to do.

    What choice was there? To continue to police almost two million hostile residents ?

    There were rockets coming from Gaza before the disengagement also. It would be even harder to close the Gaza border with settlers going in and out.

    Now that B’H you don’t hear about soldiers and settlers being killed in Gaza it’s easy to think it was a mistake. Had they still been there amongst almost two million hostile residents it would be a different story.R’L

  3. You all forgot one more thing after Sharon gave away Gush Katif he became comatose and never woke up from it and died unconscious. Hashem does not like his land given up and the worse was even the dead had to be removed. The hot houses that they left behind, where Gates the rich man bought for the PA, was destroyed with everything else. I guess giving up Gush Katif was definitely a bad idea for all concerned.

  4. This guy could touch up on the English language but he does make a lot of sense. He’s speaking very practical.

  5. The Gaza Expulsion of 9,000 Jews was a terrible decision. Proof to this is PM Ariel Sharon’s Heavenly punishment – 8 years comatose and then died shamefully with a handful of people. The Expulsion did not stop rockets but brought the rockets closer to Israel.

  6. There was a reason why these 9000 Jews were thrown out of their homes and the land was taken away from us. The land vomit out the people because the gay parades being ignored. Why did not the settlers come help the chareidim fight these gay parades. Thats why the chareidim remained silent when these settlers got nebech evicted. It was a decree for allowing the land to be polluted. Even the graves of 50 Jews buried there was uprooted. Truly the land vomited even the dead Jews some who died in combat for the stinking atheistic israeli government. How some of these young kids can salute an Israeli flag after being evicted by a right wing government is crazy. Some got smart and became chareidim. Some kids went off the derech. And some families who lost their farms and life savings moved away from Israel to start their farms in other countries. This is the Zionist. Satmar Rebbe was smart. He knew how evil these apikorsim really are. They don’t care about any Jew. It’s only the fat cat politicians. They want to turn israel into a Hebrew speaking Portugal. That’s what rabbi Meyer kahane wrote. We must stand up and demand every israeli jewish kid be given a Torah education in their public schools. Otherwise leave the government.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here