
Israeli Housing and Construction Minister Yitzchok Goldknopf stated on Tuesday that he planned to take part in the Memorial Day service at the military cemetery in Kiryat Gat, brushing aside objections from mourning families in the city who expressed discomfort over a chareidi figure attending the event.
A group of bereaved relatives sent a letter to Goldknopf, pleading with him not to appear. “We, several bereaved families from Kiryat Gat, ask you in every way possible not to attend the Memorial Day ceremony for IDF fallen soldiers in Kiryat Gat,” the letter read.
The families went on to say, “We believe that someone representing groups in Israeli society who refuse to bear the burden of military service cannot stand before bereaved parents and speak on a day that is so sacred to us.”
Goldknopf, who leads the chareidi United Torah Judaism party, has been a vocal opponent of drafting chareidi men into the army.
In their letter, the grieving families said they would rather see Goldknopf spend his time “recruiting yeshiva students” than addressing them at the cemetery.
Sources close to Goldknopf told Channel 12 News that “no negotiations are underway to replace him” and confirmed that he was determined to attend the ceremony.
This wasn’t the first time Goldknopf had been assigned to the Kiryat Gat event. He had been designated to attend last year as well, and after similar backlash from families, he ultimately chose to withdraw.
One of the signatories, Chaim Saadon — whose brother Avner died in service in 1974 — urged Goldknopf to step aside this year and allow another official to participate in his place.
“As a bereaved family, we feel that there is a moral and ethical offense to our feelings here,” said Saadon to Channel 12. “As soon as everyone enlists in the army, I’ll leave him be, but it cannot stand that someone who doesn’t enlist in the army should come and speak at the Memorial Day ceremony.”
The IDF has reported a significant personnel shortage, stating that it needs around 12,000 additional troops, including roughly 7,000 for combat roles.
At present, nearly 70,000 chareidi men aged 18 to 24 are technically eligible for conscription but have not joined the military.
On Sunday, the High Court of Justice issued an interim ruling requiring the state to clarify why it had not issued a sufficient number of draft notices to chareidi yeshiva students to fulfill the army’s needs, and why it had failed to implement the notices that had been issued. The court gave the government until June 24 to submit a written explanation addressing those failures.
{Matzav.com Israel}
Fair enough
The Chutzpa.
How about Yair Lapid and anyone who called to refuse orders (which seems majorly contributed to the Oct. 7 attack), should not appear…
This (Zionism) is idolatry. Their invented and idolatrous “Memorial Day” is not “sacred”, at least not in the Jewish faith.
Regarding him attending, the truth is that it would be better for frum Jews to avoid attending anything not Jewish (including Zionist events like this). However, it is idolatrous (again) and wrong of them to make an issue of him attending because of his not having served in the Zionist army and because he opposes chareidim doing so.
Let’s be very clear. The chareidim have been in the holy land for centuries, long before the Zionists invaded a century ago against the will of the chareidim there. The Zionist army is simply a non-starter for Jews because it is an indoctrination center of Zionist shmad and also makes its inductees violate all three of the inviolable sins: idolatry, immorality and spilling blood. Therefore, there is nothing wrong with him attempting to console these families despite their army (like Zionism) being diametrically opposed to Judaism.
Wow.You tell ’em!
You should just shut up. because you are worse then Herzl. You aren’t a Shomer Torah U’Mitzvos person, but claim to be a Tzaddik. Enjoy your time with Herzl in h—
You sound like such sweet and happy person….
Goldknopf’s attending Memorial Day ceremony to honor those who were murdered by the Zionists: Prof. Yakov Y. Dehan Hy”d, Rabbi Meir Kahane Hy”d, Rabbi Uzi Meshulam Hy”d, Rabbi Moshe Blau Hy”d, R’ Pinchas Sagalov Hy”d, the 18 Jews on the Irgun ship Atalena Hy”d, the 46 Kedoshim massacred in Meron Lag B’omer 5781 Hy”d, hundreds of patients murdered in hospitals in 5780 Hy”d, thousands from the toxic vaccines Hy”d and the 1400 massacred Simchas Torah 5784 Hy”d.
Refuah shleima!
Same to you.
He should not attend if he isn’t wanted
The halacha is that you are not allowed to be menachen avel an enemy as this may cause them even more pain. (Rama 335:2)
What purpose is there in Goldknopf attending when he is unwanted other than creating more animosity?
Well …… The country is on fire and all events have been cancelled.