“Everyone in My Yeshiva Goes to a Psychologist”: The Interview That May Change How the Chareidi World Views Therapy

Anyone entering the office of Rabbi Menachem Ingber is immediately struck by the wall lined with diplomas, certifications, and professional credentials. Yet behind those framed accomplishments stands a fascinating life story that bridges seemingly opposite worlds: American openness and chassidic discipline, the therapist’s office and the Rebbi’s room.

One of the most respected figures in the field of mental health in the chareidi community, Rabbi Ingber recently sat down for an extensive Hebrew interview with Kikar HaShabbat in which he discussed his unusual journey, parenting, therapy, shidduchim, trauma, and the emotional challenges facing Klal Yisroel today.

Matzav.com presents portions of the interview in English for our readership.

The American Boy Who Wanted a Gartel

Before discussing his work, Rabbi Ingber felt compelled to clarify a common misconception.

“I completed my master’s degree in psychology more than thirty years ago,” he explained. “When we came to Eretz Yisroel, there were certain requirements I still needed to complete in order to receive the Ministry of Health’s official psychologist’s license. By then I was already the father of eight children, and the practical realities of life made it difficult. Instead, I entered professional clinical practice. I am a recognized psychotherapist and have worked for years in welfare services, the National Insurance Institute, and the military.”

His path toward psychology began much earlier.

Rabbi Ingber grew up in what he describes as a modern Yekke home in America. His father began as the principal of a kiruv school before later becoming a professor of psychology.

“I grew up in a modern Yekke environment,” he recalled. “The natural path for me would have been Yeshiva University. Then one summer, shortly after my bar mitzvah, I attended a camp where there were chassidim, and something clicked.”

What attracted him was not merely the clothing or customs.

“I was drawn to the warmth, the varemkeit, and the understanding that serving Hashem involved more than learning. There was tefillah, chesed, and a complete way of life.”

Among all the chassidic groups he encountered, Ger made the strongest impression.

“I saw people who could live in both worlds. They were successful businessmen and genuine chassidim. Later, when I came to Eretz Yisroel, I saw avreichim arriving to daven Minchah with the Rebbe. They wore jackets and gartlach, but beneath them you could still see the green pants from army reserve duty. I loved that balance.”

Choosing a Different Path at Fourteen

The decision to become a chassid at fourteen was not something his parents embraced immediately.

“Of course it worried them,” he said. “They didn’t simply let me do whatever I wanted.”

When he began growing long peyos, his parents called him in for a serious conversation.

“They told me, ‘This isn’t how things are done.’ I answered with a sentence that still guides me today: ‘You taught me that the most important thing in life is yiras Shamayim. I believe this is my path.’”

Eventually a compromise was reached. The full chassidic dress would wait until he came to Eretz Yisroel.

Looking back, Rabbi Ingber sees the experience as a powerful lesson in parenting.

Parents, he says, need to distinguish between technical limitations and essential limitations.

He offers the example of a child who excitedly discovers rumors of an ancient mikvah beneath a neighborhood building and wants to start digging.

“The tired parent says, ‘Don’t make a mess.’ But the wiser response is, ‘Interesting idea. Let’s see what would actually be involved.’ Let him dream.”

Too many children stop dreaming because they hear too many versions of “No.”

“A child says he wants to become a singer. The parent immediately responds, ‘Be a talmid chacham instead.’ But the child isn’t thinking about fame. He sees someone inspiring people and bringing them together. He wants to make a difference.”

The dream should be encouraged, even if practical limitations eventually shape the path.

A Life-Changing Directive from the Pnei Menachem

Ironically, despite growing up around psychology, Rabbi Ingber initially pursued a rabbinic career.

He learned in kollel, received semichah, taught shiurim, and served in rabbinic capacities in Yerushalayim.

The turning point came through the future Ger Rebbe, the Pnei Menachem.

A struggling bochur in the yeshiva had become withdrawn and isolated. Rabbi Ingber was asked to learn with him and provide encouragement.

Gradually, the young man emerged from his shell and reconnected with his peers.

When the Pnei Menachem heard what had happened, he summoned Rabbi Ingber.

“He told me, ‘I hear your father is a psychologist. Apparently there are psychological genes in your family.’”

Then came the directive that would shape the rest of his life.

“‘You’re already married, you have children, you’re American—you won’t be corrupted. Go study psychology.’”

Rabbi Ingber followed the advice. More than thirty years later, he remains deeply involved in helping people navigate emotional struggles.

Feeling at Home Everywhere

One of Rabbi Ingber’s most distinctive qualities is his ability to move comfortably between very different worlds.

He speaks Hebrew, Yiddish, and English fluently and interacts naturally with people from across the Jewish spectrum.

“I once came home and told my wife, ‘Something must be wrong with me.’”

That day had begun with a lecture at Hebrew University. From there he davened Minchah with a religious Zionist minyan at the Kosel. Later he listened to a secular street musician near Machane Yehudah. That evening he learned with his chavrusa in Ger’s main beis medrash.

“I felt at home everywhere.”

The lesson, he says, is simple.

“We are all Jews. We don’t have to become identical. But we do need connection.”

The Three Foundations of Emotional Resilience

Through years of clinical work and his involvement in trauma and resilience organizations, Rabbi Ingber developed a framework he frequently teaches to parents.

According to his model, emotional resilience rests upon three pillars: identity, community, and skills.

Identity means understanding who you are, including your strengths and weaknesses.

Community means having meaningful connections—family, friends, shul, yeshiva, and community.

Skills are the practical tools needed to navigate stress, conflict, and life’s challenges.

Too many parents, he argues, spend their lives reacting.

“A child acts out, and we punish. A problem appears, and we respond. Instead, parents need to lead.”

The goal is not to force every child into the same mold.

The goal is to understand each child’s unique personality while maintaining clear and consistent boundaries.

Breaking the Stigma

Perhaps the most sensitive part of the conversation centered on the lingering stigma surrounding therapy and shidduchim.

Years ago, Rabbi Ingber delivered a lecture to teachers in Bnei Brak about ADHD and behavioral challenges. To avoid discussing others, he used examples involving his own son.

That evening he received an unexpected phone call from Rebbetzin Shoshana Alter.

“She told me, ‘Menachem, you said your son has behavioral and attention difficulties? You don’t have married children yet. Be careful what you say publicly about your children.’”

Years later, when that son entered shidduchim, a prospective family actually remembered the lecture.

The Rebbetzin had been right.

Yet Rabbi Ingber believes the community has changed dramatically.

“Today people understand much more.”

Seeking help, he insists, is not a sign of weakness.

“Psychologists are not for crazy people. Most of the people we see are normal, intelligent, successful individuals—roshei yeshiva, avreichim, top bochurim—who are stuck at a particular point in life.”

His message is simple:

“Getting help is not a deficiency. It’s a form of wisdom.”

A Nation Living Through Trauma

As someone who works extensively with emergency services and trauma-response organizations, Rabbi Ingber believes the Jewish people are still living inside an ongoing traumatic event.

“In the past, PTSD was measured in weeks or months after an event. Today, we’re not ‘after’ the event. We’re still inside it.”

The constant uncertainty affects everyone.

A passing motorcycle can trigger panic. A loud noise causes people to jump. The stress seeps into parenting, marriages, and even spiritual life.

Sometimes, he says, it causes people to become more rigid in their Judaism.

The challenge is remembering that Torah was given to bring connection and joy, not fear.

The Secret of Venasnu

When asked what one lesson people should focus on today, Rabbi Ingber pointed to the word venasnu.

The word reads the same forward and backward.

“When you give, you receive.”

Helping others, listening to others, and accepting people who are different from us are among the greatest sources of emotional resilience.

He recently spoke with an educator who visited the sites of the October 7 massacre and emerged with a painful realization.

“I spend my life learning Torah and working on my middos, but I realized I need more ahavas Yisroel.”

Rabbi Ingber believes strengthening those bonds—between communities, between parents and children, and between Jews of all backgrounds—is one of the most important challenges facing the Jewish world today.

He concluded with a powerful illustration.

Imagine a room filled with the greatest rabbanim, roshei yeshiva, admorim, and philanthropists in the world. Together they number only nine men. They cannot recite Kaddish, Kedushah, or Barchu.

Then a simple thirteen-year-old boy walks in.

Suddenly there is a minyan.

Suddenly all those giants can sanctify Hashem’s Name.

“That,” Rabbi Ingber says, “is the power of every Jew and every child. Every single person matters.”