Israel’s Sephardic Chief Rabbi Rav Dovid Yosef has expressed that in order to secure the release of hostages held by Hamas, Israel should agree to free terrorists responsible for murdering Jews.
“My father (Chacham Ovadiah Yosef) ruled very clearly that it is permitted and you must release terrorists, even many terrorists, even murderers with blood on their hands, in exchange for hostages. I’m not in the negotiations room, I don’t know what the conditions are, and what is being offered for what, so I can’t give my opinion on the negotiations as a whole. However, on this specific matter of releasing terrorists I stand and say clearly: yes, you must release terrorists to free hostages,” Rav Yosef shared in an interview with Kikar Hashabbat.
He clarified that his position stems from his father’s guidance. “It’s based on the ruling by my father, father wrote this ruling before the Entebbe operation, I was with father at the time, he wrote this major ruling which is quoted in his Sefer Yabia Omer that you must release terrorists.”
When questioned about concerns that these terrorists could return to violence, the Chief Rabbi responded: “We know that the terrorists aren’t going to become righteous people, therefore, we have to make prevention efforts, such as expelling them to other countries, but the Halachic question here is about an immediate danger to the hostages versus a future danger, and father answered that the immediate danger comes first.”
He also recalled his encounters with the families of the hostages. “Since the first moment, since the beginning of the war, here in this room have sat dozens of representatives of the hostages’ families. When you meet them it’s heartbreaking, I couldn’t hold back, sometimes they live without knowing if they are alive and some of them imagine how much they suffer, it’s impossible not to cry for their pain.”
{Matzav.com}
What would Chacham Ovadia say today about his decision on Shalit deal back then? I wonder. And who says that you have a right to base today’s decision based on a psak on a totally different set of circumstances from years past?
Just talking out loud.
I was so annoyed when I saw the headline. Release those beasts??? Then I read the article and, listening to Rav Ovadia, can understand how Hashems nissim COULD cover the fate of those terrorists, and in parallel, how the safety of our hostages MIGHT be up to us at this time.
Kill 10 or 100 or 1000 terrorists for every hostage until until all the hostages or bodies are returned and see how fast they stop taking hostages.
Complete Nonsence!! The Maharam of Rotenberg- no less than a RISHON, זצק”ל , refused to be ransomed from jail at an exorbitant price. The Pasak he gave on Gilart Shalit, שר”י, led to the direct murder of hundreds of Israelies. Yishmael is a פרא אדם, and that is the only consideration!!
Rav Dovid Yosef shlit”a is a posek. Why don’t you take it up with him instead of being motzi shem ra and talking loshon hora on a gadol?
What’s happening in the kitchen?