A growing storm is brewing within the chareidi community over Israeli Communications Minister Shlomo Karhi’s proposed media reform, with educators and public figures warning that the initiative could expose thousands of yeshiva bochurim to unrestricted television and secular media content.
While much of the criticism surrounding Karhi’s reform has centered on political and regulatory concerns, many in the chareidi world say the far greater issue is the potential spiritual danger posed by dramatically expanded access to television programming.
According to details revealed Tuesday, part of the reform would make Israeli television channels and news broadcasts available through a single free state-sponsored application accessible to every citizen.
Under the proposal, viewers would no longer need subscriptions to television providers, special streaming services, or complicated browser access. Instead, anyone could simply open the app and immediately watch television content.
Critics say the result could be unprecedented exposure to secular media among young chareidim.
A source involved in discussions surrounding the reform warned that the proposal could cause serious spiritual damage to the chareidi public.
“If this reform passes, it is going to be a disaster for the chareidi public and particularly for yeshiva bochurim,” the source said. “I heard a senior official in the Communications Ministry say: ‘Our interest is to make television accessible in Israel to populations that are not exposed today’ — meaning the chareidi and Arab public. Now you understand how dangerous this reform is?!”
Chinuch leaders also voiced strong opposition to the plan, arguing that it would place unrestricted television access just one click away from yeshiva students.
“This is a dangerous move that the representatives in the Knesset must fight against,” education officials warned. “It will be a disaster if every bochur has all television networks available at the push of a button, without protection or filtering on the content, leaving them directly connected to secular media culture.”
Political sources within the chareidi parties are likewise expressing concern that some lawmakers may not fully appreciate the broader consequences of the legislation.
“I very much hope that Shas will not make deals with Karhi in order to pass the law,” one chareidi political source said. “Perhaps they do not fully understand the implications of the reform and the amount of damage it could cause to young bochurim.”
The source stressed that the legislation likely cannot pass without support from the chareidi parties.
“It must be understood that without the chareidim, this law has no chance of passing,” the source said. “That is why pressure and public outcry are necessary to ensure they do not mistakenly support it.”
{Matzav.com}
Smartphones are assur! If you own one or have one in your possession, you are going straight to gehenom with no chance of parole. Do not pass go. Do not collect $200. You will not be revived at techiyas hameisim. All of your children must be immediately kicked out of their Yeshivos and Bais Yaakov’s.
I’m not getting the issue here that makes it worth fighting over . A Yeshiva Bochur who has access to devices that can open APPs is not under more spiritual danger if the TV app on it is free. He already has access to social media and all sorts of other garbage.
I don’t understand. I they going to force everyone to have a phone with this app? Chareidim usually don;t have phones that could use this app.
I don’t understand. Don’t they all have flip phones anyways? And if they do have smartphones and not filtered, then what difference is it if that propaganda is “free” or paid?