Not sure that a wild cat, phone & /or gun are all in the same catagory,,,
Is fone filtered? What type of fone? What type of gun? Was it found in a public place or in a private area? Many other questions can be asked…
Let an American posak address this question too.
My Father found a wallet with identification belonging to a Goy . He gave the wallet to a friend who had a beard to return the wallet so the Goy would make no mistake about who had returned the wallet to him
Lots and lots of questions about this.
-Who’s the posek?
-Why can we preemptively assume it has no filter and it’s being used for shmutz?
-Can we assume the owner has no legit need for the phone (e.g. texting, video conferencing, GPS, as a WIFI hotspot, googling info when on the go, purchasing, travel info when in a foreign country or strange city, etc)?
-I know people who carry a company-owned smartphone per their job requirement. Losing their phone can harm their career. Is that not a concern?
-Can you also smash someone’s computer, since that can be used for the same shmutz?
-Per the “cat skin” psak, could the finder simply wipe it and resell it?
(FWIW, these questions are not coming from a nogeah bedovor; I use an ancient flip-phone.)
Very interesting. (and probably the last time I will bother to hear this speaker, as he may not approve of my looking for enlightenment on the internet.)
As long as you wear a white shirt and consume only Chalav Yisroel & Paas Yisroel, you’ve got a guaranteed entrance into gan eden. If you are missing any of the 3, it’s gonna be very hot down there.
The ignorant FRUMIES are the cause of all the hatred among the normal educated Jews. You can see them all over the world by the way their “yarmakah” sticks out of the back of their black hats to show that they are wearing a “yarmakah”! FLAMBOYANT IS THE WORD!
Before destroying the tuma phone, unlock it, find the owner, give him a serious mussar talk, then rip the wig off his wife’s head, and burn it together with the phone. If arrested for doing that, plead insanity with a religious exemption. When released, join Lev Tahor.
Um, return it to it’s owner?
What if you find a gun?
A gun – keep.
This is insane, and surely not the halacha. The cases are not even comparable!!
Not sure that a wild cat, phone & /or gun are all in the same catagory,,,
Is fone filtered? What type of fone? What type of gun? Was it found in a public place or in a private area? Many other questions can be asked…
Let an American posak address this question too.
My Father found a wallet with identification belonging to a Goy . He gave the wallet to a friend who had a beard to return the wallet so the Goy would make no mistake about who had returned the wallet to him
Lots and lots of questions about this.
-Who’s the posek?
-Why can we preemptively assume it has no filter and it’s being used for shmutz?
-Can we assume the owner has no legit need for the phone (e.g. texting, video conferencing, GPS, as a WIFI hotspot, googling info when on the go, purchasing, travel info when in a foreign country or strange city, etc)?
-I know people who carry a company-owned smartphone per their job requirement. Losing their phone can harm their career. Is that not a concern?
-Can you also smash someone’s computer, since that can be used for the same shmutz?
-Per the “cat skin” psak, could the finder simply wipe it and resell it?
(FWIW, these questions are not coming from a nogeah bedovor; I use an ancient flip-phone.)
I posted a comment there asking for the name of the posek
A very strange pesak. The phone may have a filter. Perhaps he needs it for business. Who are you Mr. Finder to decide the device is “dangerous”.
What about an unvaccinated person who is lost and asks you for directions???
Great question!
It would be a mitzva gedolah to guide him to the nearest vaccination clinic.
Help him install Wayz on his cell phone. Then vaccinate him.
He is talking about a phone that has no filter and that has smutz on it. He is not talking about a filtered kosher smart phone
What if you find a pack of cigarettes…
Or a box of matches…
Or a candy. a baby might choke on it…
Where does the insane fanaticism end?
Very interesting. (and probably the last time I will bother to hear this speaker, as he may not approve of my looking for enlightenment on the internet.)
As long as you wear a white shirt and consume only Chalav Yisroel & Paas Yisroel, you’ve got a guaranteed entrance into gan eden. If you are missing any of the 3, it’s gonna be very hot down there.
WHY NOT NAME the “LEADING POSEK”??????????? who is the posek please?!?!?!?!!?????
The ignorant FRUMIES are the cause of all the hatred among the normal educated Jews. You can see them all over the world by the way their “yarmakah” sticks out of the back of their black hats to show that they are wearing a “yarmakah”! FLAMBOYANT IS THE WORD!
Before destroying the tuma phone, unlock it, find the owner, give him a serious mussar talk, then rip the wig off his wife’s head, and burn it together with the phone. If arrested for doing that, plead insanity with a religious exemption. When released, join Lev Tahor.
Keep this going or else we’ll get more vaccinations…
That (unknown) Posek likely forbids Video Recorders too, so this Halachic Vid is ‘Mute’ (Excuse the pun).
As a lubavitcher chosid that has a “online semicha” program, he himself probably has a smart phone!
Seems to be another way of skinning a cat.
so if you find a stolen car you should blow it up because cars are dangerous?
To be able to say anything you need to finish Sholcan aruch
If not u do not haive das tora