Shalit Captive for 1,600 Days; Hamas Shows No Sign of Compromise


shalitThe family and friends of Gilad Shalit commemorate today 1,600 days of his captivity amidst Hamas terrorists. His mother called on Prime Minister Binaymin Netanyahu to “make a courageous decision” and agree to the price set by Hamas for his release.

Netanyahu has said that the price — freedom for 1,000 imprisoned terrorists as well as all female and teenage terrorists — is simply too high.

A leading terrorist who was once arrested in hopes of enticing Hamas to free Shalit has been arrested again. Palestinian Authority sources reported that the secretary-general of the PA Legislative Council, Mahmoud Al-Ramhi, was arrested on Tuesday, as part of a wave of 11 arrests made by the IDF in Ramallah. Al-Ramhi, a leader in Hamas, was arrested in the past following Shalit’s abduction in June 2006, and was held for two years in hopes that his imprisonment would speed up Shalit’s release.

The IDF says Al-Ramhi has returned to terrorist activity of late. Hamas condemned Israel for the arrest, saying that it has “returned to the policy of arresting political leaders of Hamas.”

Hamas has refused to allow even neutral observers, such as International Red Cross representatives, to visit Shalit throughout the 52 months of his captivity. Human Rights Watch (HRW) has condemned Hamas, calling its treatment of Shalit as “cruel and inhuman” and saying it illustrates the UN definition of torture. HRW also said Hamas is in violation of the international rules of war by prohibiting him from having contact with his family or visits from the Red Cross.

Shalit was in his tank on the Gaza border when he was captured by Hamas terrorists who had tunneled from Gaza to Israel. Two other soldiers in his tank crew were killed: 2nd Lt. Chanan Barak and Sgt. Pavel Plotzker. Shalit was taken to Gaza, and his whereabouts have never been ascertained. Contact with him since then totals the following: He has apparently received one letter throughout his time in captivity, three letters have been received from him, a tape of him reading a letter aloud was released in June 2007, and a videotape of him reading another statement was released in September 2009.

Four cities around the world – Paris, Rome, Miami and New Orleans – have granted Gilad Shalit honorary citizenship. The tent erected in Jerusalem near the Prime Minister’s residence will be lit up today and tomorrow in an extra-special manner to commemorate the 1,600th day since Gilad’s capture. In addition, a rally is scheduled to be held in Washington, D.C. today demanding that Hamas release its prisoner; 1,600+ people, including Ambassador to the U.S. Michael Oren, are expected to be on hand.

Gilad’s mother Aviva Shalit wrote a letter to Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu for the occasion, pressuring him to “wake up” and make the “courageous decision” to respond positively to the Hamas demands for her son’s release. Hamas demands the release of 1,000 terrorists imprisoned in Israel, as well as freedom for all female and under-age terrorists similarly incarcerated.

“It’s been more than a year and a half,” Mrs. Shalit wrote, “that Gilad has been paying the terrible price of your inability to make a decision… [Friends and family] are sick of hearing excuses from you why it is impossible [to agree to the Hamas demands]. I have already heard all the possible excuses and explanations. Gilad deserves, after 1,600 days in darkness, more than excuses and explanations.”

In fact, however, Netanyahu has made a decision – namely, not to pay the exorbitant and dangerous price set by Hamas. “The State of Israel is willing to pay a heavy price for Gilad Shalit’s release,” Netanyahu has said, “but it cannot say that it will pay ‘any’ price.”

Read more at Arutz Shevah.

{Arutz Shevah/}


  1. according to the secret Israeli intelligence, the deal that brought back E. Tannenbaum and three bodies of soldiers costed afterwards the lives of approximately 30(?!) Israelis. One Shalit captive is bad enough! Are the demonstrators willing to lose focus of reality that fast, and thereby to create chas v’shalom many more “Shalits”?

  2. The only comment worth making is to edit the copy. Should have led with “The family and friends of Gilad Shalit (Gilad ben Aviva), etc.”

  3. there is no way israel can make the exchange, they would be killing tens and maybe hundreds of more israelis by releasing these prisoners. how are supporters of this deal blind to this? we all wish schalit will return home safely but you cant say his life is more valuable than the numerous israelis who may get killed from the release of these terrorists.

  4. I would very much want to hear daas torah on this situation, I personally dont see how you can release terrorists, and thereby endanger many others, for just one man. may hashem send a yeshua.

  5. Prayers for Gilad Shalit.

    Time waits for no man. The piecemeal, stop-start discussions via various mediators have been helpful but a breakthrough has not been achieved. The danger is that the stasis will lead to frustration and possible violence. If people perceive that there is no hope for the future then things can collapse.

    As I have been pointing out lately, high level trust building initiatives must take place in the next six months. The intentions and approaches can be done in the next few hours and days. There are lines of communication open between all the parties. Thank G-d everyone has not completely retreated to their trenches waiting for the next barrage. It is not surprising anymore that so many people are blind to this latent demand. Visionaries always suffer until people realise they indeed are correct, and then everyone claims the credit for the idea. Such is life…

  6. Daven, appeal to the RED CROSS, letter writing to the UN, publicize his plight at every Arab gathering and garnish publicity for his release. This is not an exchange policy, he is a prisoner of war and there are suppose to be laws to protect him. Have the EU and Human Rights groups rally also.