Israeli Finance Minister Betzalel Smotrich has announced his intention to continue subsidizing day care for families of chareidi men who dodge the draft, despite objections from Attorney General Gali Baharav-Miara.
The dispute centers on funding for chareidi men of military draft age, underscoring ongoing tensions over chareidi integration into the workforce and military service.
Smotrich fired off a detailed letter to Deputy Attorney General Gil Limon and Finance Ministry Legal Adviser Assi Messing. In it, he argued that canceling the daycare budget would severely hamper chareidi women’s entry into the workforce, impede the sector’s job market integration, condemn it to poverty, and overstep the government lawyers’ authority.
Smotrich expressed outrage that the decision was made between government lawyers without consulting him as finance minister.
“It’s astounding that you conduct discussions, exchange correspondence, and make far-reaching budgetary and economic decisions among yourselves without even considering it appropriate to involve the finance minister or seek his position. This is a state within a state,” he wrote.
“The premise for this decision—that daycare subsidies are given to support the father’s Torah study—is fundamentally flawed, based on a misinterpretation of the Supreme Court ruling on yeshivah funding after the conscription plan expired. This assumption is baseless.
“The subsidy has nothing to do with the father’s Torah study. It’s meant to incentivize mothers to enter the workforce by helping finance childcare,” the letter said.
“The subsidy’s declared goal is to promote chareidi women’s integration into the job market. The government decided to extend it to mothers whose husbands study in yeshivah and aren’t home. This practical decision recognizes a simple reality: In chareidi families where fathers study Torah, mothers often stay home with children, even at the cost of poverty and a low standard of living.”
The finance minister argued that daycare subsidies have led to many chareidi women entering the workforce.
“It’s been an overwhelming success. The past two decades have seen a dramatic rise in chareidi women’s employment. One would have to be blind not to see the positive impacts on the economy, chareidi society, and the nation as a whole,” he wrote, contending that cutting daycare subsidies would deal a severe blow to the economy.
Smotrich demanded that the legal advisers “immediately retract your fundamentally flawed opinion. Allow me to continue my economic policy supporting growth and chareidi women’s workforce integration. Refrain from illegally and unreasonably sabotaging it and the economy. By virtue of my authority as finance minister, I’m ordering the continuation of daycare subsidies, per Industry, Trade and Labor Ministry criteria.”
Anticipating a High Court challenge, Smotrich wrote, “If you believe my decision is illegal, you’re free to petition the Supreme Court. There, I’ll demand independent representation” rather than have the Attorney General’s Office represent his ministry.
The finance minister concluded with sharp criticism, “It’s hard to escape the feeling that regarding the chareidi public and its budgets, you’re repeatedly driven by a hostile agenda that seeks every possible way to harm and obstruct. If only you’d invest a fraction of the energy you spend trying to cut ultra-Orthodox budgets in helping me prevent state funds from leaking to criminal organizations, in fighting black market capital, and more.” JNS
{Matzav.com Israel}
This is not a dictatorship or government run by the politburo or Duma. This is a democracy which means it’s run by the people for the people. The AG is not Mrs. Putin is Mrs. Xijanping. Betzalel is bold, strong and thankfully a man of conviction! Kol Hakavod.