Still A Mystery: Egyptair Plane Made ‘Sudden Swerves’ Before Vanishing Over Mediterranean


Search-and-rescue teams from several nations combed the Mediterranean Sea late Thursday for possible survivors and debris from an EgyptAir plane that fell from the sky with 66 people aboard.

Shortly before the aircraft was scheduled to land, it abruptly turned and dropped steeply before vanishing from radar and plunging into the water between Greece and Egypt, triggering concerns of terrorism.

The disappearance of the plane was the country’s third air incident since October, eroding confidence in the safety of Egypt’s air travel and delivering another blow to the government’s efforts to revive its struggling economy and tourism sector.

EgyptAir said earlier in the day that bits of wreckage had been found near the Greek island of Karpathos, about 250 miles from the Egyptian coast. But a senior Greek air-safety official said on state television that the debris did not belong to the aircraft, and the airline later retracted its statement.

Investigators emphasized they were leaving open all possibilities, but a top Egyptian aviation official suggested that terrorism seemed more likely than a technical failure.

“The possibility of a terror attack is higher than a malfunction, but again, I don’t want to hypothesize,” Egypt’s civil aviation minister, Sherif Fathy, told reporters without giving further details.

U.S. officials cautioned that it was too early to determine what brought down the plane. Rep. Adam Schiff (California), the ranking Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee, said there was not yet enough evidence to “draw any conclusions.”

“There certainly are reports that it broke apart in midair that I think are credible,” Schiff said, “but the cause of that is still not known. We haven’t seen claims of responsibility yet, and we don’t have the specific intelligence to draw any conclusions yet.”

The Airbus A320 left Paris at 11:09 p.m. local time Wednesday. It flew as scheduled across Europe, passing over northern Italy and down the Adriatic coast. Nothing seemed amiss when the pilot spoke with Greek air traffic controllers at 2:26 a.m.

As the plane left Greek airspace, the pilot “was in good spirits and thanked the controller in Greek,” according to Greece’s civil aviation agency.

But shortly after entering Egyptian airspace, the plane made “sudden swerves” and dropped from 37,000 feet to 15,000 feet, said Greece’s defense minister, Panos Kammenos.

The first turn was a sharp, 90-degree veer to the east after the plane passed over the Greek island of Karpathos, Kammenos told reporters in Athens. Then the plane made a full circular loop – a “360-degree turn,” Kammenos said.

“We cannot rule anything out,” Egyptian Prime Minister Sherif Ismail said at Cairo’s airport.

Earlier, there was conflicting information about whether officials had received a distress signal from the aircraft. The airline said it received one from Flight 804, but the Egyptian armed forces later said they were unaware of such a signal.

Of the 66 people aboard, 56 were passengers, including two infants and one child. Seven were crew members, and three were security personnel.

French authorities told reporters at a news conference that it is usual practice for EgyptAir to have three security officers onboard.

No Americans were on the flight, according to the airline. Among those aboard, it said, were 30 Egyptians, 15 French nationals, two Iraqis, and one passenger each from Algeria, Belgium, Britain, Canada, Chad, Kuwait, Portugal, Saudi Arabia and Sudan.

In Washington, President Obama directed U.S. officials “to reach out to their international counterparts to offer support and assistance,” White House spokesman Eric Schultz said.

A Pentagon spokesman, Capt. Jeff Davis, said a U.S. P-3 Orion surveillance aircraft will join the search teams. Britain also planned to send a plane and a ship.

Officials in Paris, where the flight began, opened investigations into why the plane vanished about 45 minutes from its scheduled landing in Cairo. French President François Hollande said it had “crashed,” but he gave no further details on what could have brought it down.

“No hypothesis is favored or ruled out at this stage,” a statement from the French prosecutor’s office said about its investigation.

U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry said he would not speculate on whether terrorism caused the crash.

“I just don’t have the information on which to base this, and I don’t think the experts have the information yet on which to base this,” he said, speaking from a NATO meeting of foreign ministers in Brussels. “And nothing does more harm to people or countries than to start speculating ahead of time, so I’m – I don’t want to do that.”

But the sudden cut from ground contact raised inevitable parallels with more recent incidents when attacks, bombs or pilot intervention, not technical malfunctions, brought down aircraft.

Egypt faces a range of militant threats, including a group affiliated with the Islamic State that is active in the Sinai Peninsula. It claimed responsibility for bringing down a Russian charter flight in October with a possible bomb smuggled aboard, killing all 224 people on a flight from the Red Sea resort city of Sharm-el-Sheikh.

In March, an EgyptAir flight from Alexandria was hijacked and diverted to Cyprus. The suspect, 59-year-old Seif Eldin Mustafa, surrendered, and all hostages were released.

In November – just a month after the Russian plane attack in Sinai – the same Islamic State-linked faction posted a video purporting to show one of its members striking an Egyptian navy vessel with a shoulder-fired antiaircraft missile. Defense experts believed the weapon was probably a Russian-built SA-18 Igla, which can hit aircraft flying at a maximum of 11,000 feet.

On Thursday, in an effort to contain the damage, EgyptAir officials stressed that their pilots were highly trained and their planes were in good condition.

The pilot of Flight 804 had more than 6,000 hours of flight experience, including more than 2,000 hours flying the same model as the vanished aircraft, EgyptAir said. The co-pilot had nearly 3,000 flying hours.

The plane had been in service for more than 17 of the previous 24 hours before the crash, traveling from Asmara, Eritrea, to Cairo, then a round trip to Tunis, before heading to Paris.

Steven Wallace, former director of the Office of Accident Investigation and Prevention at the Federal Aviation Administration, called it “heavy utilization for that kind of aircraft.”

“But I don’t see that as a safety issue as long as the normal flight checks were made,” he added.

Manufactured in 2003, the plane was powered by International Aero engines and had about 48,000 flight hours, Airbus said.

Relatives of passengers were kept in a lounge with on-site doctors and translators at the Cairo airport. They left after a few hours and were told to await updates by phone. One man with four relatives on the plane said he knew “nothing.”

Amr Sami, a regional EgyptAir spokesman at Charles de Gaulle Airport in Paris, told The Washington Post that EgyptAir flights from the French capital would continue as scheduled.

Meanwhile, family members of those aboard began streaming into a makeshift crisis center at a hotel near the airport. As French police ushered them in, they were tearful and bewildered, some pushing strollers with small children. They did not speak to reporters.

(c) 2016, The Washington Post · Heba Habib, Sudarsan Raghavan 



  1. There are “experts” and then there are experts.

    It is not a mystery about what happened with Flight MS 804. As I publicaly stated and wrote 25 hours ago…

    An on-board bomb brought down the flight. It was an act of terrorism. In all probability by the Islamic State who have repeated their modus operandi of the Metrojet Sinai downing. The bomb was not big enough to blow the plane out of the sky immediately, thus it continued in a straight line, blazing away like a shooting star. It’s last movements through the sky were reported by a captain of a merchant ship who reported a ‘flame in the sky’ about 130 nautical miles south of the Greek island of Karpathos. Island residents also reported the fire in the sky.

    UPDATE 13:26 IDT Fri. 20th May 2016

    In a strange twist of fate it looks likes the resting place of the plane is at about 3010 metres below the surface of the Mediterranean Sea within a few kilometres of the resting place of the Israeli Navy submarine INS Dakar which sank on 25th January 1968 at 33°30′ 02 N 29°29′ 58 E. The Egyptian Navy has just reported finding debris including passenger items. It is not too windy or cloudy at the search area now so the visibility is good.

Leave a Reply to Adam Neira Cancel reply

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here