Giuliani: ‘Anything is Legal’ in War


Former New York mayor Rudy Giuliani, one of Donald Trump’s most trusted campaign advisers, suggested today that laws don’t apply during times of war.

In an interview with ABC News’ “This Week” that aired Sunday morning, Giuliani defended Trump for saying last week that the United States should “take the oil” in Iraq as part of the “spoils of war” and to keep it out of the hands of the Islamic State militant group. It’s an idea that Trump has offered on the campaign trail numerous times over the past year, even as foreign policy experts question its legality and practicality.

Giuliani said Trump does not necessarily want the United States to extract the oil itself but wants to “leave a force back there and take it and make sure it’s distributed in a proper way.”

“That’s not legal, is it?” ABC’s George Stephanopoulos asked, as the Geneva Conventions forbid seizing the natural resources of a sovereign nation after invading it.

“Of course it’s legal. It’s a war,” Giuliani said, laughing. “Until the war is over, anything’s legal.”

Several of Trump’s foreign policy and national security proposals have hit the same roadblock: national and international law.

Trump has called for a temporary ban on allowing most Muslims into the country, a proposal that many have deemed unconstitutional. He has called for the return of waterboarding and for killing relatives of terrorism suspects, both of which are forbidden under the Geneva Conventions.

When it comes to waterboarding, Trump has clarified his remarks to say that he would not force the military to break the law but that he would push to change the law so that waterboarding would be legal.


(c) 2016, The Washington Post · Jenna Johnson 



  1. “Until the war is over, anything is legal.” Well said.

    The Palestinians, ISIS, Al Queda, and all the other chayos have been operating under this principle from the beginning. Actualy, their motto is “everything is legal always.”

    The US is beginning to go back to that principle (as they did in WWII), by ignoring the collateral damage in UAV strikes, The Israelis are too PC to ever do that. When Moshiach comes, he will enforce this motto to the hilt, and it will be all over for the sitra achra.